Fabrication of three-layer graded magnesium foam by means powder metallurgy and spacer method with an application in bioimplants: macro morphology, microstructure and compressive properties evaluation

Document Type : Research Article

Authors
New Technologies Research Center, Amirkabir University of Technology
Abstract
In this paper a three-layer graded magnesium foam with a potential application in bone implants is produced by means of powder metallurgy and spacer method. The gradation is based on the density variation between the layers. In order to so, three different combinations of magnesium powder and carbamide particles (used as the spacer) are considered in three layers and the graded structure is compacted under a pressure of 300 MPa and finally sintered at 400°C for 4 hours. SEM analysis and compression tests are conducted on the produced specimens to determine the microstructure and mechanical properties of the graded foam, respectively. The results show that increasing the percentage of the carbamide spacer can lead to producing open cell foam. This means that this kind of foam can be used for repairing bone tissue scaffolds. In addition, while the mechanical properties of bulk magnesium implants are far from that of a compacted human bone, the produced three-layer graded foam can resemble spongy bone structures properties excellently. Furthermore, similar mechanical properties to human spongy bone can be obtained by gradation of the foam rather than applying single layer foams. This means that potentially, the three-layer graded magnesium foam may be utilized in human bone implants.
Keywords
Subjects

[1] S Singh, N Bhatnagar, A survey of fabrication and application of metallic foams (1925–2017), Journal of
Porous Materials 25 (2018), 537-554. 
[2] A Kulshreshtha, SK Dhakad, Preparation of metal foam by different methods: A review, Materials Today:
Proceedings 26 (2020),1784-1790.
[3] T Wan, Y Liu, C Zhou, X Chen, Y Li, Fabrication, properties, and applications of open-cell aluminum foams:
A review, Journal of Materials Science & Technology 62 (2021), 11-24.
[4] CM Runyan, JA Taylor, Clinical applications of stem cells in craniofacial surgery, Facial Plastic Surgery 26
(2010), 385-395.
[5] KM Fischer, KY Morgan, K Hearon, D Sklaviadis, ZL Tochka, OW Fenton, DG Anderson, R Langer, LE
Freed, Poly(Limonene Thioether) scaffold for tissue engineering, Advanced Healthcare Materials 5(2016), 813-
821.
[6] H Niknejad, H Peirovi, M Jorjani, A Ahmadiani, J Ghanavi, AM Seifalian, Properties of the amniotic
membrane for potential use in tissue engineering, European Cells and Materials 15 (2008), 88-99.
[7] C Shuai, S Li, S Peng, P Feng, Y Lai, C Gao, Biodegradable metallic bone implants, Materials Chemistry
Frontiers 3 (2019), 544-562.
[8] M Khazaei, M Mehdi Nezhad Nori, M Hasanzadeh, M Rezaei, Synthesis of porous zirconium-based metalorganic framework nanostructure for detoxification of chemical pollutants, Advanced Materials and Novel
Coatings 34 (2020), 2452-2460.
[9] E Marukawa, M Tamai, Y Takahashi, I Hatakeyama, M Sato, Y Higuchi, H Kakidachi, H Taniguchi,T
Sakamoto, J Honda, K Omura, H Harada, Comparison of magnesium alloys and poly-l-lactide screws as
degradable implants in a canine fracture model, Journal of Biomedical Materials Research 104 (2016), 1282-
1289.
[10] R Balasubramanian, R Nagumothu, E Parfenov, R Valiev, Development of nanostructured titanium implants
for biomedical implants – A short review, Materials Today: Proceedings 46 (2021), 1195-1200.
[11] G Uppal, A Thakur, A Chauhana, S Bala, Magnesium based implants for functional bone tissue regeneration
– A review, Journal of Magnesium and Alloys 10 (2022), 356-386.
[12] S Kazemi, H Eivaz Mohammadloo, H Yeganeh, Modification of Hydroxyapatite-based coating in the
presence of Zirconium for implant application: Corrosion, Structure and Surface study, Advanced Materials and
Novel Coatings 40(2022), 3018-3031.
[13] S Jayasathyakawin, M Ravichandran, N Baskar, CA Chairman, R Balasundaram, Mechanical properties and
applications of Magnesium alloy – Review, Materials Today: Proceedings 27 (2020), 909-913.
17
[14] MP Staiger, AM Pietak, J Huadmai, G Dias, Magnesium and its alloys as orthopedic biomaterials: A review,
Biomaterials 27 (2006), 1728-1734.
[15] G Song, Control of biodegradation of biocompatable magnesium alloys, Corrosion Science 49 (2007),
1696-1701.
[16] K Hong, H Park, Y Kim, M Knapek, P Minárik, K Máthis, A Yamamoto, H Choe, Mechanical and
biocorrosive properties of magnesium-aluminum alloy scaffold for biomedical applications, Journal of the
Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials 98 (2019), 213-224.
[17] Y Bi, Y Zheng, Y Li, Microstructure and mechanical properties of sintered porous magnesium using
polymethyl methacrylate as the space holder, Materials Letters 161 (2015), 583-586.
[18] XC Xia, XW Chen, Z Zhang, X Chen, WM Zhao, B Liao, B Hur, Effects of porosity and pore size on the
compressive properties of closed-cell Mg alloy foam, Journal of Magnesium and Alloys 1 (2013), 330-335.
[19] J Banhart, Manufacture, characterisation and application of cellular metals and metal foams, Progress in
Materials Science 46 (2001), 559- 632.
[20] CE Wen, Y Yamada, K Shimojima, Y Chino, H Hosokawa, M Mabuchi, Compressibility of porous
magnesium foam: dependency on porosity and pore size, Materials Letters 58 (2004), 357-360.
[21] GL Hao, FS Han, WD Li, Processing and mechanical properties of magnesium foams, Journal of Porous
Materials 16 (2009), 251-256.
[22] L Yilong, Q Guibao, Y Yang, Lv Xuewei, B Chenguang, Preparation and compressive properties of
magnesium foam, Rare Metal Materials and Engineering 45 (2016), 2498-2502.
[23] SF Aida, H Zuhailawati, AS Anasyida, The effect of space holder content and sintering temperature of
magnesium foam on microstructural and properties prepared by sintering dissolution process (SDP) using
carbamide space holder, Procedia Engineering 184 (2017), 290-297.
[24] P Gupta, M Adhikary, M Kumar, N Bhardwaj, BB Mandal, Biomimetic, osteoconductive nonmulberry silk
fiber reinforced tricomposite scaffolds for bone tissue engineering, ACS Applied Materials and Interfaces 8
(2016), 30797-30810.
[25] Z Hao, Z Song, J Huang, K Huang, A Panetta, Z Gu, J Wu, The scaffold microenvironment for stem cell
based bone tissue engineering, Biomaterials science 5 (2017), 1382-1392.
[26] A Ajdari, P Canavanb, H Nayeb-Hashemi, G Warner, Mechanical properties of functionally graded 2-D
cellular structures: A finite element simulation, Materials Science and Engineering A 499 (2009), 434-439.
[27] GH Loh, E Pei, D Harrison, MD Monzon, An Overview of functionally graded additive manufacturing,
Additive Manufacturing 23 (2018), 34-44.
[28] Y Li, Z Feng, L Hao, L Huang, C Xin, Y Wang, E Bilotti, K Essa, H Zhang, Z Li, F Yan, T Peijs, A review
on functionally graded materials and structures via additive manufacturing: From multi-scale design to versatile
functional properties, Advanced Materials Technologies 5 (2020), 1900981-1901012.
[29] AJ Wagoner Johnson, BA Herschler, A review of the mechanical behavior of CaP and CaP/polymer
composites for applications in bone replacement and repair, Acta Biomaterialia 7 (2011), 16-30.
[30] F Witte, N Hort, C Vogt, S Cohen, KU K.ainer, R Willumeit, F Feyerabend, Degradable biomaterials based
on magnesium corrosion, Current Opinion in Solid State and Materials Science 12 (2008), 63-72.
[31] U Riaz, I Shabib, W Haider, The current trends of Mg alloys in biomedical applications A review, Journal
of Biomedical Materials Research Part B Applied Biomaterials 107 (2018), 1970-1996.
[32] Q Tian, J lin, L Rivera Castaneda, A Tsanhani, ZS Dunn, A Rodriguez, A Aslani, H Liu, Nano-tosubmicron
hydroxyapatite coatings for magnesium-based bioresorbable implants – Deposition, characterization,
degradation, mechanical properties, and cytocompatibility, Scientific Reports 9 (2019),810-836.
[33] J Asadi, B Korojy, SA Hosseini, M Alishahi, Effect of cell structure on mechanical and bio-corrosion
behavior of biodegradable Mg-Zn-Ca foam, Materials Today Communications 28 (2021), 102715.
[34] SO Agbedor, D Yang, J Chen, B Saleh, SO Seidu, C Qiu, J Jiang, A Ma, Reactive sintering principle and
compressive properties of porous AZ91 magnesium alloy foams produced by powder metallurgy approach,
Materials Science and Engineering Technology 53 (2022), 244-259.
[35] EF Morgan, GU Unnikrisnan, AI Hussein, Bone mechanical properties in healthy and diseased states,
Annual Review of Biomedical Engineering 20 (2018), 119-143.
[36] A Kulshreshtha, SK Dhakad, Preparation of metal foam by different methods: A review, Materials Today:
Proceedings 26 (2020), 1784-1790.
[37] KE Matheson, KK Cross, MM Nowell, AD Spear, A multiscale comparison of stochastic open-cell
aluminum foam produced Via conventional and additive-manufacturing routes, Materials Science and
Engineering A 707 (2017), 181-192.
19
[38] H Bafti, A Habibolahzadeh, Production of aluminum foam by spherical carbamide space holder techniqueprocessing parameters, Materials and Design 31 (2010), 4122–4129